Satya has ceased publication. This website is maintained for informational
All contents are copyrighted. Click here to
learn about reprinting text or images that appear on this site.
AR Arguments Against Heifer International?
I’ve really liked how the recent issues have provided a variety of
perspectives on ethically complicated issues (e.g. cage-free eggs, happy
The Heifer Project seems similarly complicated morally. Animal protectionists
are torn it seems because they care about poor humans and animals, and feel they
have to choose one over the other when asked for an opinion on the organization.
The blogging I’ve seen on this recently and the short pieces on it online
haven’t impressed me much, even the Jack Rosenberger piece from [Satya,
February] 2001 seems to only glance the surface of the issue. The best argument
against Heifer is that it sows the seeds of greater exploitation. Maybe this
is true, but the case hasn’t been developed convincingly. The kinds of
alternative development projects (e.g. fruit tree planting) recommended by some
aren’t robustly justified either.
I would really like to see some people dig into this: look more at what Heifer
is actually able to achieve, what its projects actually look like on the ground
(intensified ag.?), etc. I would love to see some Carol Adams-esque criticism
of their advertising/media, a Friends of Animals-type piece on Heifer’s
moral worldview, and the reasoned analysis of a Vegan Outreach article on the
outcomes of Heifer Project interventions.
Thanks so much for February’s Satya. It’s the first time I’ve
read your magazine, having only discovered your website recently, linked from
a yoga website. Satya is fantastic. The articles are extremely well written and
researched by professional writers with the gift of capturing the reader’s
intellect, curiosity and heart.
As a spiritual person, I am a vegan by need (I have allergies to the protein
in dairy products) and a vegetarian by choice. The purpose of this e-mail is
simply to praise your work with Satya.
It seemed to me that many of the articles in Satya’s February issue about
social activism related to [Andrew] Harvey’s ideas of healing America,
for which goal he has established the Center for Spiritual Democracy. One of
the words he has coined that sums up part of his philosophy is “Coca-Coma,” our
way of life that is “absolutely addicted to such nervous hysteria and multitasking
that nobody has the inner peace to connect with the silence of the divine.”
I was also surprised and happy to see so many vegan restaurants and food suppliers
advertised in your February issue. This is most helpful to your readership. I
once lived in Brooklyn’s Park Slope section and am delighted to now learn
(and proud, too, since I was born in Brooklyn) that this New York borough is
full of wonderful writers, editors and critical thinkers with such a depth of
vision and spiritual understanding.
Emily K. Benjamin