September
1997
Echoes
of the Holocaust
Book Review by Charles Patterson
|
|
|
Prisoned Chickens, Poisoned Eggs: An Inside
Look at the Modern Poultry Industry by Karen Davis, Ph.D. Book
Publishing Company: Summertown, TN 1997. $12.95 pbk. 176 pages
After the main character in Isaac Bashevis Singer's
short story, "The Letter Writer," thinks about the ways animals are
treated, he concludes that "all people are Nazis" and that for the animals
it's "an eternal Treblinka."
Nowhere in America is the might-makes-right fascist
mindset more in evidence than in the poultry industry's exploitation
and slaughter of billions of defenseless chickens. Nowhere is the image
of "eternal Treblinka" more apt than with respect to the mass murder
that takes place at killing centers euphemistically called "poultry
processing plants."
In Karen Davis's important new book about the
American poultry industry, she describes the hellish worlds of the two
main genetic types of chickens created by the modern poultry industry
-- broiler chickens slaughtered by the billions for meat and laying
hens exploited by the millions for eggs (and then slaughtered). The
book paints a vivid picture of the natural needs and instincts of chickens,
which Davis knows about firsthand from her care of rescued chickens,
and contrasts it with the degradation and distress chickens suffer from
hatchery to slaughter. The catalogue of cruelties includes: mutilation,
crowding, injuries, diseases, debeaking, forced molting, antibiotics,
ammonia burn, heat stress, cutting off the combs and toes of breeding
chickens, horrendous experiments conducted by "poultry science" university
departments, the mass killing of male chicks born to laying hens by
suffocation, gassing, and grinding them up, and the constant exposure
of chickens to what Terrence Des Pres called "the excremental universe"
in his description of Nazi concentration camps.
In a chapter called "Death," Davis describes
the prolonged and tortured killing of chickens at the poultry processing
plants. After the chickens are yanked out of their cases and clamped
by the feet upside down on moving racks which drag them through electrified
water, workers cut their necks and leave them to bleed to death slowly
in bleed-out tunnels. Their deaths can take up to nine minutes. In the
never-ending quest to find more efficient ways to kill chickens, modern
poultry researchers are looking for alternatives to present stunning
methods. One of their ideas is to gas the chickens inside their transport
crates. That would eliminate the carcass damage caused by the handling
involved in removal and shackling. The researchers' gas of choice would
be hypoxia mixed with small amounts of carbon dioxide and argon.
During World War II, Germans tried something
similar: in their search for more efficient ways to kill "sub-humans"
they built gas vans which gassed their victims while the vans drove
them to a mass grave. The three large stationary vans set up by the
Germans in the woods near Kulmhof (Chelmno) in Wartheland in late 1941
became the first of the six Nazi extermination camps.
Prisoned Chickens, Poisoned Eggs is a powerful
wake-up call to a nation in a moral stupor. Anybody who eats chicken
or eggs after reading this book should go straight back to school and
take a refresher course in reading comprehension.
© 1997 by Charles Patterson
Charles Patterson, Ph.D. is the
author of Animal Rights, The Civil Rights Movement, and The Oxford 50th
Anniversary Book of the United Nations.